I once did an escape room with a group of business owners. We were all accustomed to solving problems, making decisions, and being in charge. Seemed like a good group to put in a room together. It was like we had assembled the Avengers, and everyone thought they were Tony Stark.
I have completed more than 83 escape rooms, in different cities, states, and countries. (Scotland was fun!) My favorite group, however, is my family of five. As it turns out, there are advantages to having people who do not all think like you. (Although my wife would probably suggest that one of me is already too much.)
For the uninitiated, an escape room is an interactive adventure in which your group searches for clues, solves puzzles, and works toward a goal before time runs out! You might be investigating a mystery or completing a mission. Some are generic themed like “The Pirate’s Curse” or “Prison Escape”. Other rooms bear a suspicious resemblance to a familiar movie, skirting the line of blatant copyright infringement, like “Henry Potter and the Philosopher’s Gem” or “Raiders for the Holy Grail.”
Now, I am fairly particular about these things. I want to feel as though I am actually in the story. The details should matter. The puzzles should belong there. And I want nonlinear play, which means several people can work on different challenges at the same time. If four of us are watching the fifth person fiddle with a combination lock, I could have saved some money and watched someone forget their locker combination.
I also want different kinds of puzzles. Give us something to find, something to calculate, a pattern to recognize. Make us communicate. I want to get to the answer and appreciate how clever it was. I have considerably less appreciation for random guessing, pointless distractions, or six versions of the same puzzle. And if you have gone to all the trouble of creating an immersive world, please do not interrupt it with a walkie-talkie announcing what we missed.
Now, back to the business owners. We had a room full of Captain Picards fighting over the captain’s chair, both literally and figuratively. The instinct to take charge was understandable. It was also considerably less useful when everyone else had the same instinct.
Then one guy put a puzzle piece in his pocket. And forgot about it. Yep. An essential piece of the puzzle had left circulation (one guy thought he was Gollum who had found His Precious?), along with our hopes of finishing.
My family operates a little differently. I am the one managing macro workflow (“put the used clues in that empty area, so we know we are done with it!”) questioning assumptions and proposing the odd solution. My wife is analytical and patient enough to work through the logic. My older daughter steps back and sees the big picture, while still catching the small details. My son is our maze puzzler and math genius. My youngest daughter looks under tables, spots things that do not match, and finds patterns the rest of us overlook.
We need all of that. If my youngest finds something, it matters, even if I am busy being convinced that I have figured everything out. My unusual idea needs someone patient enough to test it. A clue one person discovers may solve the puzzle somebody else is working on. Keeping it to yourself is not particularly helpful. (Neither is keeping it in your pocket, Gollum.)
When you are trying to solve a problem, you need people who see it differently. You need someone who can step back and see the big picture, and someone who catches the detail everyone else missed. You need patience to work through the logic, along with a willingness to question whether you are approaching the whole thing the wrong way. You also need to share what you know. Listen when someone notices something you missed. Let the person with the right skill take the lead. If you get stuck, hand it over. If your idea does not work, stop defending it. And if everyone is busy proving they are the smartest person in the room, you are burning time without making progress.
Anyway, we were talking about escape rooms. I think.