Tales from the Front
By Timothy Wan, Esq.
Baseball movies generally end when the hero hits a walk-off home run and wins the big game. The crowd erupts, the music swells, and everyone goes home happy. Collection lawyers know better. A “home run” is not getting a judgment. It’s not the end of the game. The “home run” is actually collecting it.
Some years ago, a longtime Major League Baseball umpire, whom I shall refer to as Harry Doyle (yes, I know Bob Uecker played the announcer, but just go with it), became the subject of a damning story told on a sports podcast. The storyteller was a superstar player, whom I shall refer to as Roger Dorn. (Or, at least, a superstar in Roger Dorn’s own mind.)
Dorn claimed that a pitcher, whom I shall naturally refer to as Wild Thing, had received a generous strike zone from Doyle during numerous games. According to Dorn, Wild Thing regularly allowed Doyle to use his luxury yacht, and Doyle returned the favor by calling strikes that were waaay off the plate. Dorn also accused Doyle of ejecting him from game after game throughout his career, apparently whenever Doyle needed something to do between innings.
Baseball may be the only industry in America where every bit of minutiae is permanently preserved in a box score. Doyle pulled the records. Wild Thing had not pitched in any of the games in which Doyle called. Not one. The official records also established that the alleged pattern of Doyle repeatedly ejecting Dorn simply did not exist. Doyle ejected Dorn but once.
The podcast tale was not merely a complaint about a missed call. It accused an umpire of essentially accepting a bribe and corrupting the integrity of the game. Doyle sued for defamation, and the Court awarded Doyle a judgment for over six figures, for the damage to Doyle’s reputation. The Court specifically recognized the potential effect of the accusation on Doyle’s chances of reaching the Baseball Hall of Fame.
But Dorn had nothing in his name. Bank accounts were non-existent. No vehicles. No real property. Unemployed, living with a girlfriend. The attorneys who obtained the judgment then retained our firm to collect it. They were the starting pitching, but they needed us, the specialist closer.
Dorn seemed just outside the reach of every pitch we threw.
Until we found that he was doing seasonal commentary for the Jobu Broadcasting Network.
We served Jobu with an income execution. The network responded that it could not comply because Dorn was not an employee. Dorn was an independent contractor and received a 1099. Now we had him.
A standard wage garnishment in New York against an employee generally reaches only ten percent of gross wages. But if Dorn was not an employee, the payments were not “pay”, right? So, they were just generic contractor receivables. As such, why wouldn’t we be entitled to pursue one hundred percent of the money payable by the network!
Jobu immediately recognized the problem. Its counsel explained that if every dollar payable to Dorn had to be sent to us, the network would simply stop using Dorn. After all, Dorn was unlikely to continue showing up and working hard if one hundred percent of the check went directly to satisfy the judgment.
Legally, we had Dorn. Practically, we were about to be shut out. One hundred percent of nothing remains nothing.
So, rather than taking every dollar until Jobu terminated the relationship, we got Dorn to agree that twenty five percent of every payment from the network would be sent toward the judgment. That was substantially better than the ten percent we would ordinarily receive through a wage garnishment, while still leaving Dorn with a reason to remain in the broadcast booth.
More importantly, Dorn agreed to provide quarterly sworn reports identifying all other professional activity and income. Commentary work. Personal appearances. Endorsements. Baseball card signings. Any other paid engagement had to be disclosed. If Dorn concealed an activity, even a single card signing, the agreement imposed substantial liquidated damages.
We did not collect the entire judgment in one swing. What we obtained was better than an empty victory against a disappearing income source. We secured a continuing stream equal to twenty five percent of the network payments, a sworn quarterly box score of every other dollar earned, and serious consequences if Dorn tried to hide the ball again.
Roger Dorn began this story by inventing a baseball game that never happened. Dorn ended it by agreeing to give us the box score for every dollar earned. And this time, we were calling the balls and strikes.